Godfrey, Leibsle, Blackbourn & Howarth, S.C.
Godfrey, Leibsle, Blackbourn & Howarth, S.C.

Schedule Your Initial Consultation Today

Elkhorn, WI

PROVIDING A FULL RANGE OF LEGAL SERVICES

Can a pre-existing condition affect your Wisconsin injury claim?

If you had arthritis, back pain or another health problem when a car crash occurred, you might worry about its effect on your injury claim. Your insurer might claim that your pain stems from an earlier condition rather than the crash.

However, having a pre-existing condition, or a health problem that predates the crash, does not mean you cannot seek compensation in Wisconsin. What matters is whether the crash caused new injuries or made your condition worse.

When can a previous condition qualify for compensation?

Wisconsin law recognizes that an accident can make an old injury or health condition worse. If someone’s carelessness causes that harm, you may seek compensation for the worsening caused by the accident, not for the condition itself.

For example, you might have had occasional back pain before a collision but developed constant pain and difficulty walking afterward. This difference matters when an insurer reviews your medical records to assess how much your condition changed after the crash.

How insurers review your past health records

Insurance adjusters may review your past medical records to question whether the accident caused your pain or other symptoms. They might:

  • Use past reports of similar pain to argue that the accident did not cause your symptoms.
  • Blame worse symptoms on aging, arthritis or another health condition.
  • Question delays in getting care or gaps between doctor visits.

These arguments can lead to disputes over what the accident actually caused. But a past diagnosis alone does not prove that the crash caused no new harm.

Why medical records and timelines matter

Medical records can help show what changed. Earlier records may describe your usual pain, treatment and what you could do before the crash. Medical exams afterward can show new pain, greater limits on movement or the need for more care.

The timing of your symptoms and medical treatment can help doctors assess whether the accident contributed to your worsening condition. Your doctor’s medical opinion can also help explain whether the accident likely aggravated your condition or whether your symptoms resulted from its natural progression.

When medical history complicates your injury claim

When an insurer questions whether your symptoms resulted from an accident, differences between your previous and current medical records can become important. Our personal injury attorney at Godfrey, Leibsle, Blackbourn & Howarth, S.C. can help you evaluate those records, address disputed medical findings and determine what compensation you may be entitled to pursue. Contacting the firm can help you understand your options when your medical history complicates your claim.

RSS Feed

FindLaw Network